Original-article audit
What this source can support
Reviewed 15 August 2026 · geometry completeness 25/100 · medium for scope findings; low for cost direction
status: three linked models present | models: dossier_url: https://www.bunkerstrategy.xyz/intelligence/countries/Sweden/fortifications/se-hangesten-alvsborg-radio-rock | subject: Älvsborg Radio rock facility | method: Archetype Derived / Archetype proxy | base_sek_2026_ex_vat: 105105000 | range_sek_2026_ex_vat: low: 38837500 | high: 285940000 | model_confidence: Very Low | assessment: The source supplies only mission and rock emplacement; every dimension and equipment quantity is proxy-derived.; dossier_url: https://www.bunkerstrategy.xyz/intelligence/countries/Sweden/fortifications/se-nya-varvet-billingen-staff-rock | subject: Billingen staff rock facility | method: Archetype Derived / Archetype proxy | base_sek_2026_ex_vat: 402542522 | range_sek_2026_ex_vat: low: 121307767 | high: 1277904356 | model_confidence: Very Low | assessment: Correctly uses two-storey command/logistics morphology but brackets all area, excavation and portal quantities.; dossier_url: https://www.bunkerstrategy.xyz/intelligence/countries/Sweden/fortifications/se-nya-varvet | subject: Nya Varvet documented fortified-scope minimum | method: Aggregate Rollup / Programme-site total | base_sek_2026_ex_vat: 259771050 | range_sek_2026_ex_vat: low: 64155520 | high: 1011277867 | model_confidence: Very Low | assessment: Appropriately excludes replacement of the whole naval base/shipyard, but is stated to include Billingen while its base value is lower than the Billingen child base; scenario nesting is not internally coherent.
Supported useThe article spans a naval-base campus and several distinct rock facilities. In 1939 Älvsborg Radio was built at Nya Varvet, a staff rock room was blasted in Billingen's east side around 1942, and the short-wave station received a separate rock room on Hängesten. In the early 1950s Billingen was extended west for stores, workshops and a two-storey staff/command space. Later sections have greater ceiling height; old sections are mould-affected because ventilation was reduced. The naval staff moved out in the 1960s because cover was insufficient, the site was not nuclear-safe and it was too urban. No protected area, excavation volume, portal count or system capacity is published. The entire Nya Varvet site was sold in 1986 for SEK 10.3m; that is not a construction cost.
Geometry evidenceinner_structure: Billingen: eastern staff rock room, later westward expansion for stores, workshops and staff/command use.; Hängesten: separate rock room for the short-wave station.; Later Billingen sections have materially greater ceiling height, but no measurement is given. | levels: count: 2 | scope: early-1950s Billingen staff/command space | evidence: Explicitly reported; does not describe Hängesten. | other: 1910 campus accommodation plan: 300 coastal artillery personnel plus 330 naval personnel; not cavern capacity.; Early 1950s campus workforce: over 1,000 temporary/permanent staff; not cavern capacity.; About 40 boats at peak; a naval-base activity metric, not facility geometry.
Historic-cost evidenceamount_sek: 10300000 | price_year: 1986 | scope: sale price for the whole Nya Varvet area to two companies | note: Land/asset transaction, not original construction cost and not the value of any single rock facility.
Systems describedNaval command/staff and communications functions in Billingen.; Stores and multiple workshop types in the expanded rock complex.; Short-wave radio function at separate Hängesten rock room.; Ventilation; reduced operation contributed to mould in older Billingen sections.; No generator, water, protection-door or communications-equipment quantities are published.
Primary cost driversBillingen cavern expansion, support and two-level inner program.; Stores/workshops versus headquarters fit-out.; Hängesten radio cavern and mission electronics.; Ventilation, moisture control and protected utilities.; Scope boundary between fortified minimum and entire naval base/shipyard.
Unit / programme scopeThree linked cost subjects must remain distinct: the inclusive documented-fortified Nya Varvet scope, Billingen as a component, and separate Hängesten/Älvsborg Radio. Campus personnel, boats and sale price do not describe one cavern.
Revision directionIndeterminate
Missing inputsMeasured plans/sections and portals for Billingen and Hängesten.; Cavern excavation and support quantities.; Inner-building/shop/store areas and structural quantities.; Radio/communications, power, HVAC and protection equipment inventories.; Explicit inclusive-parent roll-up logic and scenario-consistent child aggregation.; Defined boundary for documented fortified scope versus whole naval base.
Site / data issuesThe complete source map correctly links three dossiers; the initial sources_full internal_dossier_urls listed only Hängesten.; The article's title and bulk of geometry concern Nya Varvet/Billingen, while Hängesten receives one sentence.; The inclusive Nya Varvet base estimate is lower than its stated included Billingen child base, indicating inconsistent scenario/roll-up logic.; The SEK 10.3m figure is a whole-site sale price, not construction or replacement cost.